Experts’ Insights on Biodiversity Law and Governance

Experts’ Insights on Biodiversity Law and Governance

Biodiversity Law in Action: Leading Global Experts Share New Insights on the implementation of Biodiversity Law through Treaties, Courts, Finance and Practice
A1. Welcome and Introductions (Part I)
“The law can be a shield for nature and for those who steward nature. But treaties and regulations, contracts and codes, courts and arbitration are also instruments for cooperation, for compliance, and for delivery.” Prof Marie-Claire Cordonier Segger (Chair, BLGI / Senior Director, CISDL / Chair in Sustainable Development Law & Policy, Univ Cambridge)
Can law keep pace with the biodiversity crisis? BLGI Chair Prof Marie-Claire Cordonier Segger argues that law can be both a shield for nature and the people who protect it, and a practical tool for cooperation, compliance and delivery. As countries take stock of their progress under the Kunming–Montreal Global Biodiversity Framework, she warns that the window to turn promises into results is closing fast.
Prof Hovhannes Hovhannisyan, Rector of Yerevan State University, reminds us that knowing more about nature is not enough unless that knowledge shapes laws and decisions, and calls on universities to train biologists who understand policy and lawyers who take science seriously. Armenia’s Minister of Justice, H.E. Srbuhi Galyan, insists that international commitments only matter once they become national legislation, accountable institutions and real results. She also points out that shared ecosystems can open doors to dialogue, even in regions marked by conflict.
Prof Markus Gehring of the University of Cambridge and CISDL and Prof Tenia Kyriazi of the International Law Association UAE Branch celebrate a decade of partnership among biodiversity lawyers, and welcome a new ILA branch in Armenia as a home for the next generation of international lawyers.
To listen about the role of law in delivering the Global Biodiversity Framework, click here:
A2. Welcome and Introductions (Part II) From Commitments to Cooperation and Compliance
“…a framework is just a promise. It is not yet protection… Law is where commitments become action.” Hon Elizabeth Maruma Mrema (UN Assistant Secretary-General / Deputy Executive Director, UNEP)
What does it take to turn a global promise into real protection for nature? UN Assistant Secretary-General Hon Elizabeth Maruma Mrema opens a conversation among the leaders of the world’s major biodiversity treaties on how to put the Kunming–Montreal Global Biodiversity Framework into action at a time of geopolitical strain. She argues that the gap between what has been agreed and what has been delivered can only be closed through legislation, institutions, enforcement and access to justice, and points to the trillions of dollars still flowing to activities that harm nature.
The answers come from those who run the treaties every day. CITES Secretary-General Hon Ivonne Higuero shows how every wildlife trade permit rests on legal and scientific judgements about legality and sustainability, and why the people who live alongside wildlife must have a real stake in its conservation. CMS Executive Secretary Adv Andy Raine offers a reason for optimism: saiga antelopes brought back from the brink and recovering turtle populations show that international cooperation still works. He also makes the case for ecological connectivity to become a principle of international environmental law.
Adv Maria-Goreti Muavesi of IUCN WCEL brings the view from the Pacific, where in some island states only a couple of officials may be responsible for environmental impact assessment, and argues that implementation is above all a question of environmental rule of law. Dr Kent Nnadozie explains why crop diversity and farmers’ rights belong at the heart of the Framework. Together, the speakers explore how treaty secretariats can work side by side, and how the new BBNJ Agreement can avoid reinventing the wheel.
To listen about how the biodiversity treaties can move from commitments to cooperation and compliance, click here:
B. From Recognition to Results: Legal and Governance Pathways for Credible OECMs
"...this isn't just about meeting...the 30 by 30 target. It's about really supporting the stewards of nature." Dr Harry D. Jonas (Director, Conservation Areas, WWF-US)
More than 7,000 sites around the world are now reported as OECMs, from community-managed forests to private farmland, and Indonesia is even considering decommissioned oil platforms. But does recognition mean that nature is actually being protected? Dr Harry Jonas and Dr Daniel Ruiz de Garibay bring together experts from around the world to find out. Dr Jonas explains how OECMs have grown from an undefined term in international law into a key tool for Target 3, while Dr Ruiz de Garibay presents CISDL–WWF research showing that most reported sites come from just a handful of countries, and proposes a test of “functional equivalence” for credible national frameworks.
The country stories are revealing. In France, Ms Laure Germain-Thomas explains, farmers and private landowners could become new conservation partners, but there are real concerns about greenwashing and paperwork. In Lebanon, where urban areas have more than doubled in 35 years, Ms Marianne A. Fahed presents a draft procedure in which recognition lasts five years and can be withdrawn if nature is not protected. In Indonesia, Mr Hari Kushardanto describes how marine OECMs are being written into law and funded through a pilot that pays only for verified results.
Ms Carolina Hazin issues a clear warning: for most reported OECMs, there is no public evidence on their effectiveness, their governance or the consent of local communities. Her answer is independent verification. As the experts conclude, recognition should mark the start of a commitment, not the end of one.
To listen about legal and governance pathways for credible OECMs, click here:
C. From Conflict to Dialogue: Implementing Biodiversity Treaties in Post-Conflict Settings
“Nature continues to connect what politics has divided.” Dr Irina Ghaplanyan (Senior Climate Change Specialist, World Bank Group)
What happens to biodiversity commitments when conflict closes borders and damages ecosystems? Lawyers, a deputy minister and a development expert explore one of the least examined questions in biodiversity law. Dr Gor Samvel argues that implementation begins with “translation”, building a shared understanding of what international obligations really require; without it, reforms may meet targets on paper while little changes on the ground. Deputy Minister of Justice Adv Anna Karapetyan describes how Armenia, a landlocked country, has nonetheless joined the BBNJ Agreement and acceded to the Nagoya Protocol, and the legal challenges of assessing damage and restoring ecosystems after conflict.
What happens with environmental treaties during armed conflict? Adv Kristine Khanazadyan explains that, noting that the CBD “follows the actor and not the map”. She also asks how to tell a genuine environmental claim from a dispute that belongs to the conflict itself, and recalls how Peru and Ecuador turned a contested border area into a protected peace park. Prof Yeghishe Kirakosyan adds that biodiversity treaties offer few binding routes to dispute settlement, even as recent advisory opinions of international courts raise the profile of environmental obligations.
Dr Irina Ghaplanyan closes with a story that captures the theme: a Caucasian leopard, believed to have lost a leg to a landmine, later recorded on the other side of a border. Drawing on World Bank work in Colombia and Central Asia, and on joint efforts to protect cranes along the Armenia–Türkiye border, she shows how shared nature can create space for cooperation where politics has stalled.
To listen about implementing biodiversity treaties in post-conflict settings, click here:
D. Rights, Stewardship and Restoration: Community-Led Conservation in Africa
“…a conservation initiative… becomes legitimate only when people can help to decide what happens to the place they are expected to care for.” Mr Anthony Simukonde (Executive Director/Founder, Greenit Enviro Management Network, Zambia)
In parts of rural Zambia, the greenest places used to be burial grounds, protected as sacred land. Today, communities are restoring green spaces around their beehives too. Stories like this show what conservation looks like when communities are in charge. Mrs Taza Mulenga Lungu and Mr Oyeoussi Charles Balogoun lead a grounded discussion, drawing on experience from Zambia and Benin, on how rights-based approaches and community stewardship can help deliver Targets 2 and 3 of the Kunming–Montreal Global Biodiversity Framework.
Mr Brighton Mutali argues that projects designed by communities, led by women and backed by secure land rights are the ones that outlast their funding, and warns that displacement for investment schemes is the greatest threat to that work. Mr Anthony Simukonde stresses that conservation is legitimate only when people help decide the future of the places they care for, and sets out what a community site would need to show to be recognised as an OECM.
Mr Oyeoussi Charles Balogoun goes to the root of the problem: people cut forests and mangroves because they need fuel to cook. His organisation’s answer, turning organic waste into biogas and fertiliser, has eased pressure on ecosystems and raised incomes. From Benin’s Mono Biosphere Reserve, Mr Maurras Akakpo describes community eco-guards and wildlife monitoring, but warns that long-term plans remain unfunded, and urges investment in evidence and legal foundations before areas are labelled as OECMs.
To listen about rights-based conservation, community stewardship and restoration in Africa, click here:
E. Financing Nature Restoration: Markets, Mandates, or Both?
“…it can fund nature whenever nature can be contracted, much like any other piece of infrastructure… Not, however, when it’s simply sold as some sort of feel-good product.” Mr Eoin Murray (Chief Investment Officer, Rebalance Earth)
Nature is the life-support system of our economies, yet it rarely appears on a balance sheet. So who should pay to restore it: investors, governments, or both? Adv Emily Julier of Hogan Lovells Cadwalader brings together finance and legal experts from New Zealand and the United Kingdom to debate the question. Mr Ian Herbert, who leads New Zealand’s BIOFIN assessment, notes that we spend less on biodiversity than on cosmetics, and proposes treating nature as an asset, with the funding gap recorded as a “deferral” that our children will inherit.
Mr Eoin Murray, an investor, is clear that private money will flow to nature only when nature can be contracted like infrastructure, such as a restored floodplain that protects a factory downstream. He explains what still holds investors back, from the lack of long-term contracts and policy uncertainty to projects too small for large funds. Adv Bryony Widdup looks at what the law can do, from the UK’s Biodiversity Net Gain scheme and its critics to tax incentives, blended finance and insurance discounts that reward nature-based flood protection.
Ms Sangeeta Laudus reminds the panel that people protect what they love, making public understanding part of the solution. The verdict: not markets or mandates, but both, with far more work needed to get finance to communities in the Global South.
To listen about financing nature restoration through markets, mandates or both, click here:
F. Closing the Restoration Gap: Proactive Law and Policy Coherence for Landscapes and Seascapes
“…it turns a promise into a duty… Without a national law, the target simply lives in a minister report.” Hon Juan Carlos Losada Vargas (Former Member, House of Representatives of Colombia)
Many countries have laws that require restoration after a mining project or an industrial accident, but almost none that require us to repair the damage that has built up over generations. Can legislation change that? Dr Victoria Gutierrez of Commonland and Ms Anita Diederichsen of WWF lead a lively exchange on how proactive law can drive restoration under Target 2 of the Kunming–Montreal Global Biodiversity Framework. Opening the discussion, UNCCD Executive Secretary Dr Yasmine Fouad reminds us that while there are three Rio Conventions, “on the ground, there is only one landscape”.
Ms Bethanie Walder of the Society for Ecological Restoration presents a forthcoming model law designed to close this “restoration legislation gap”, complete with sample objectives, targets, finance provisions and permits “designed to do good”. Prof An Cliquet explains what the world can learn from the EU Nature Restoration Regulation, the most comprehensive binding restoration law to date, which reaches even into cities and farmland.
Former Colombian congressman Hon Juan Carlos Losada Vargas offers a lawmaker’s view: without a law, a restoration target stays on paper, and one ministry may restore what another destroys. Lasting laws, he argues, are built across party lines and rooted in communities, because “governments and parliaments change but communities do not”. Adv Joann Lee describes a growing network of parliamentarians working on restoration laws, and Mr John Colmey explores how AI could help investors find credible local projects.
To listen about proactive law and policy coherence for landscape and seascape restoration, click here:
G. Access and Benefit-Sharing in a Crowded Regime: DSI, the WIPO Treaty and the Search for Coherence
“Access and benefit sharing has never had more instruments, but we need to construct a coherent system.” Prof Markus W. Gehring (Professor in European and International Law, Univ Cambridge / Lead Counsel, CISDL)
Genetic resources, and the digital data drawn from them, help produce new medicines, crops and products. But who should share in the benefits, and how? Prof Jorge Cabrera Medaglia and Prof Markus Gehring bring together leading experts to examine the latest developments in access and benefit-sharing, from the new Cali Fund for digital sequence information to the WIPO Treaty on intellectual property and genetic resources. As Prof Gehring puts it, the challenge is to build a coherent system in which a user who follows the rules of one treaty does not break those of another.
Dr Pedro Batista welcomes the new multilateral approach to digital sequence information but points to its weak spots, including the lack of a definition and contributions that remain voluntary, and suggests ways to avoid users paying twice or not at all. Prof Chidi Oguamanam, sees the new Treaty as a turning point that links benefit-sharing to the patent system and gives Indigenous peoples and local communities a real voice.
Prof Srividhya Ragavan argues that the Treaty mainly improves patent quality and may even weaken countries’ leverage once traditional knowledge enters public databases. Adv Manuel Ruiz goes further, asking whether, after three decades, access and benefit-sharing has actually helped conservation, and proposing a new model built on “natural information”.
To about new developments in the Nagoya Protocol and regime interaction in access and benefit sharing regimes, click here:
H. Nature on Trial: How Courts Are Shaping Biodiversity Law, Rights and Duties to Future Generations
“Nature cannot appear before a court. Forests cannot file constitutional complaints. Rivers cannot defend themselves. And endangered species cannot appoint lawyers.” Hon Judge Prof Marcel Szabó (Justice, Constitutional Court of Hungary)
When a three-year-old girl came to the Lahore High Court because smog kept her from school, her garden and her grandparents’ house, the court heard her case. Hon Judge Jawad Hassan tells this story as he joins senior judges from Hungary and Germany to discuss how courts are shaping biodiversity law, environmental rights and duties to future generations. He explains how Pakistani judges read the right to life as including a right to a healthy environment, and turned international soft law into binding jurisprudence.
Hon Judge Prof Marcel Szabó of Hungary’s Constitutional Court explains how his country’s constitution treats biodiversity as part of the nation’s common heritage, and how the Court protects the options, quality and access of future generations. He recalls an ordinance of Empress Maria Theresa that protected certain oak trees from being felled before they were 200 years old, as a reminder of how deep this sense of duty runs. His advice to fellow judges: “be brave”.
Hon Judge Dr Martin Borowsky describes how a series of diesel-emissions cases led him to recognise rights of nature under EU law, an idea he calls a “reverse legal transplant” from the Global South, while admitting that lawmakers are better placed than judges to take it further. Adv Nina Pindham closes with a powerful argument: if the climate and biodiversity crises violate fundamental rights, they are failures of the rule of law, and independent courts are part of the answer.
To listen about how courts are shaping biodiversity law, rights and duties to future generations, click here:
I. Beyond the Numbers: The High Seas Treaty, Target 3 and Rights-Based Marine Conservation
“Target 3 is not simply a numerical goal. It is an opportunity to build a marine conservation that is effective, equitable, and durable.” Ms Arianna Beeray (High Seas Youth Ambassador, Trinidad and Tobago)
The high seas cover more than 60 per cent of the ocean’s surface, yet only around 1.5 per cent of them is protected. With the new High Seas Treaty preparing for its first Conference of the Parties, Adv Masha Kalinina of The Pew Charitable Trusts and High Seas Youth Ambassador Ms Arianna Beeray lead a conversation about how to change that, and how to do it fairly. As Ms Beeray puts it, the question is not only how much ocean we protect, but how, for whom and with whose knowledge.
Mr Fariz Ahmadov, a Canadian negotiator, draws three lessons from the Convention on Biological Diversity: involve Indigenous peoples from the start, build on sound science, and avoid “paper parks” that exist only on maps. Ms Candeze Mongaya of Rare shows how Indonesia’s marine spatial planning and consent rules, and the Philippines’ Indigenous-led biodiversity strategy, could guide the Treaty’s early work.
Hawaiian elder Mr Solomon Kaho offers a very different view of the high seas. Far from being empty and unknown, he explains, these waters have long been crossed by Pacific voyaging canoes, whose navigators know their winds, currents and migrating animals. In his people’s worldview, humans belong to nature rather than ruling over it, and he calls for Indigenous peoples to have a seat at the decision-making table, not just a mention in the text.
To listen about the High Seas Treaty, Target 3 and rights-based marine conservation, click here:
J. Youth at the Riverbank: Turning Global Biodiversity Targets into Local Action
“…targets agreed at a COP only matter when they reach the riverbanks, wetlands, and green spaces where people actually live.” Mr Nico Roman (Vice-Chair, Global Youth Council on Science, Law & Sustainability)
Global biodiversity targets only matter if they reach the rivers, wetlands and green spaces where people live. Young leaders from England, Burkina Faso, the United States and beyond share how they are making that happen. Mr Nico Roman describes paddling from Cambridge to the North Sea, working with fellow youth advisers on a declaration for the future of the Fens now signed by more than 500 people, and campaigning for the rights of the River Cam.
In Burkina Faso, Ms Michelle Bidima and her peers earned a role in revising the national biodiversity strategy by first proving themselves through action on the ground, from river restoration to the management of shea parklands. Yet, she notes, lack of funding still keeps many young people out of international negotiations. Mr Seth Thomas explains how young people briefed mayors and state legislators new to the CBD, and why youth need to be named in targets on finance and monitoring if they are to be counted.
Mr Jeremi Trojak and Mr James Bonsall show how community education and volunteering can turn passion into long-term engagement, and Mr Matthew Carvalho urges young people to arrive at negotiations with concrete proposals, while holding the door open for those who come next. Ms Vienna Swampy of the Samson Cree Nation closes with a message for everyone: it starts with you.
To listen about youth engagement and local biodiversity governance, click here:
K. Indigenous Laws, Legal Pluralism and the Rights of Nature in Latin America and the Caribbean
“We must move from participation to influence, from consultation to co-decision and from representation to leadership.” Adv Dalia Fernanda Márquez Añez (Global Co-Chair, UNEP Women’s Major Group)
Latin America has become a laboratory for some of the boldest ideas in environmental law, from constitutions that recognise the rights of Mother Earth to court rulings that protect rivers. Prof María José Lubertino brings together women leaders and lawyers from across the region to ask how Indigenous laws, legal pluralism and diverse ways of valuing nature can reshape the Kunming–Montreal Global Biodiversity Framework. Ms Berta Medrano opens with a sobering finding: the Framework’s targets on participation, justice and gender equality remain far off track, with only a few countries, including Colombia, Mexico and Chile, fully reflecting them in their national plans.
Ms Xiomara Acevedo argues that markets alone cannot save nature, and highlights Panama’s initiative, joined by Vanuatu and Tonga, towards a universal declaration on the rights of nature. Adv María Paula González Espinel explains why the Escazú Agreement, which guarantees access to information, participation, justice and protection for environmental defenders, is essential in a region where more environmental defenders are killed than anywhere else.
Adv Dalia Fernanda Márquez Añez insists that Indigenous peoples are rights holders, not stakeholders, and calls for a shift from consultation to genuine shared decision-making, backed by funding for Indigenous women’s organisations. With a contribution from Ms Paula Alvarado Mamani, the discussion closes with Prof Lubertino’s call for an ecofeminist approach to law that would allow anyone to defend ecosystems in court.
To listen about legal pluralism and the rights of nature in Latin America and the Caribbean, click here:
L. From Commitments to Delivery – Biodiversity Law in Practice
“…if you have a stake in the future of our planet, our one and only home, you are already part of the nature conservation community by definition.” Dr Grethel Aguilar (Director-General, International Union for Conservation of Nature, IUCN)
Commitments are made in negotiating rooms, but they are delivered by lawyers, financiers, researchers and public officials. What do they need to do differently? IUCN Director-General Dr Grethel Aguilar calls for pollution, climate change and biodiversity loss to be tackled together rather than “in separate boxes”, backed by binding commitments and real accountability. Reporting from inside the CBD negotiations, Mr Tim Scott of UNDP expresses that progress is off track, but finds hope in the fact that nearly 200 governments keep meeting, arguing and searching for consensus.
Drawing on a development bank’s experience, Adv Vesselina Haralampieva of the EBRD explains why money alone is not enough: investors need laws that are clear, consistent, enforceable and predictable, and biodiversity commitments must be written into project contracts with milestones and remedies. Adv Bryony Widdup describes how law firms can train commercial lawyers to work for nature, and how finance law can channel investment through blended finance and supply chains.
Prof Carlos Andrés Echeverry Restrepo highlights the role of universities in connecting law, science and local knowledge, while Ms Audrey Wagner explains why the biggest obstacles to implementation are social and political rather than technical, making legal and governance research more important than ever.
To listen about putting biodiversity law into practice, from commitments to delivery, click here:

Hosted by CISDL, Univ Cambridge, Univ de Costa Rica, Univ Javeriana Cali, Univ Externado de Colombia

To explore strategies from leading experts for integrating biodiversity protection into agroecological practices click here

Hosted by Raoul Wallenberg Institute on Human Rights & Humanitarian Law-Lund Univ, Global Network for Human Rights and Environment (GNHRE)

Hosted by Charles De Visscher Center for Intl & European Law (CeDIE) at Université catholique de Louvain (Univ Louvain)

To learn about the role of biodiversity law in armed conflict click here

Hosted by Youth for Ecocide Law (Y4EL), Stop Ecocide International

To discover how ecocide laws can strengthen climate and biodiversity commitments click here

Sharing Experiences from the Commercial Frontline - Financing 30/30

Hosted by Hogan Lovells

Hosted by CISDL, Univ Cambridge, Univ de Costa Rica, Univ Javeriana Cali, Univ Externado de Colombia

Hosted by Univ Externado de Colombia, Instituto Interamericano de Justicia y Sostenibilidad (IIJS), IUCN, UNEP

 

Scroll to Top